8.2 C
New York
Wednesday, November 19, 2025

Buy now

The Greatest Bitter Cream Mashed Potatoes Recipe


These fluffy mashed potatoes are creamy buttery and scrumptious topped with melted butter and chives. Bitter cream and loads of butter give them their signature creamy texture! I exploit yukon gold potatoes, however russet potatoes are an incredible substitute. The proper aspect dish for Thanksgiving or different particular vacation meals!

Fluffy sour cream Mashed Potatoes in a large bowl topped with melted butter and chives. Fluffy sour cream Mashed Potatoes in a large bowl topped with melted butter and chives.

Seize a Potato Masher…

As a result of there’s lower than 2 weeks to Thanksgiving, and meaning we’re making the last word aspect dish: MASHED POTATOES!!! Not simply any mashed potatoes both, we’re making my secret ingredient bitter cream mashed potatoes. Simply wait till you serve these… folks go CRAZY over them and would possibly struggle over leftovers.

Lots of people love garlic mashed potatoes, however I feel my secret ingredient mashed are even higher. The key ingredient? Horseradish, which provides a ton of taste to this well-known aspect dish, and may have folks begging you for the recipe. Belief me, I’ve made these for the final 8 years and we by no means have leftover mashed potatoes.

A bowl of fluffy mashed potatoes topping with melted butter and chives.A bowl of fluffy mashed potatoes topping with melted butter and chives.

Which is definitely type of unhappy, as a result of I positive do love leftover mashed potatoes. I ought to in all probability double the recipe this yr and deal with myself. I feel I’ll double the inexperienced bean casserole and pumpkin pie whereas I’m at it.

Yukon gold potatoes and sour cream for making mashed potatoes.Yukon gold potatoes and sour cream for making mashed potatoes.

The Substances

  • Potatoes: I really like Yukon gold potatoes for this recipe, however in a pinch, russet potatoes work nice! I’ll notice that I discover Yukon gold potatoes give an additional creamy texture. Whereas russet potatoes are inclined to make additional fluffy mashed potatoes. However each choices are scrumptious!
  • Salt and Pepper: You’ll add salt to the chilly water for boiling the potatoes, which infuses the potatoes with taste. Then you definitely’ll add salt and pepper once more for seasoning.
  • Entire Milk: I don’t counsel subbing low fats milk or utilizing plant based mostly milks on this recipe. The reason being that plant based mostly milks (and diminished fats milks) gained’t give the potatoes the best texture and taste.
  • Heavy Cream: Aka whipping cream, provides the mashed potatoes an additional wealthy taste and creamy texture.
  • Butter: I like to make use of unsalted butter, in order that I can management the quantity of salt added. However salted butter will work. You’ll add melted butter to the mashed potatoes recipe, after which have the choice of including extra melted on prime. I like to recommend doing each, for that basic creamy buttery style and texture!
  • Bitter Cream: Once more, I counsel utilizing full-fat bitter cream right here. It provides a ton of taste and helps create an additional creamy texture. In a pinch, plain full-fat Greek yogurt might work. However it’s going to change the style and texture a bit.
  • Horseradish: Aka the key ingredient to my favourite mashed potatoes! Whereas the horseradish gained’t make your potatoes style spicy or overwhelmingly like horseradish. It does add a magical taste that folks simply go loopy over! And it makes the potatoes pair nice with lamb, steak, turkey, and so forth.
  • Chives: This ingredient is non-compulsory, however I really like topping the melted butter with chives. The chives add a pop of shade and texture. And the style goes nice with the creamy potatoes and refined horseradish taste.
Cut potatoes in a large bowl.Cut potatoes in a large bowl.

Lower the Potatoes

  • This recipe calls for five kilos of yukon gold potatoes. You should utilize russet potatoes as an alternative, however I’d advocate peeling them, for those who do make this change.
  • Should you’re utilizing yukon gold potatoes, you don’t must peel them. Which is able to prevent a very good period of time. However you will want to scrub them after which chop them into 1-inch items. This will eat as much as 20 minutes of your time. So that you’ll wish to issue that in time clever.
  • I don’t counsel chopping the potatoes too far prematurely, as they’ll flip brown when uncovered to air. Except you employ the little trick under which is nice for time saving.
  • Lower the potatoes then submerge them in a bowl of chilly water. Place the bowl within the fridge for as much as 24 hours. Then use as directed under within the mashed potatoes recipe!
A bowl of mashed with creamy texture.A bowl of mashed with creamy texture.

Cook dinner Till Fork Tender

  • When you chop your potatoes, you’ll place them in a big pot of salted water.
  • Carry the water to a rolling boil and prepare dinner the potatoes for about quarter-hour.
  • You wish to take a look at the potatoes beginning at round 12 minutes. They need to be mushy and fork tender.
  • Simply take care to not over prepare dinner the potatoes, which may trigger gluey mashed potatoes.

Bounce to the recipe under for the complete ingredient checklist and recipe!

Close up of melted butter on top of potatoes.Close up of melted butter on top of potatoes.

What to Serve with Mashed Potatoes?!

Whereas the reply may appear apparent (turkey, duh!). I needed throw a couple of extra choices out for you:

  • Herb Crusted Rack of Lamb
  • Beef Stew (That is my favourite pairing for mashed potatoes)
  • Beef Chili (Don’t knock it until you strive it!)
  • Caesar Salad
  • Lemon Garlic Salmon
  • Inexperienced Beans
  • Stuffing
  • Pan-Seared Scallops (We make scallops and mashed potatoes virtually each Valentine’s day… so romantic!)

On the finish of the day, you may pair mashed potatoes with virtually something! Or make the mashed potatoes the primary course, and go loopy with the toppings. My aunt made a mashed potato bar for our engagement social gathering and it was an enormous hit! She put the mashed potatoes in a big dish and surrounded it with bacon, a wide range of cheeses, scallions, cubed ham, chives, and extra!

Bowl of mashed potatoes topped with melted butter.Bowl of mashed potatoes topped with melted butter.

Can I Make these in Advance?

Sure, you may completely make these prematurely and reheat earlier than your meal. I wish to reheat my mashed potatoes in a double boiler, over medium warmth, stirring usually. This gently reheats the mashed potatoes and helps stop them from getting gluey or loosing their fluffy creamy texture.

These is perhaps a bit of extra work than instantaneous pot mashed potatoes or one pot mashed potatoes, however I promise they’re value it! for those who’re making these for a aspect dish this Thanksgiving, let me understand how they end up within the feedback part under!

Extra Potatoes Recipes:

Previous article

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles